Are there any American institutions left that are capable of
reconciling freedom of speech with the responsibility to speak reasonably, to
limit self-expression to less hurtful forms than we've experienced in the last
couple of decades? At one time, I believed the American criminal justice
system, grounded in the Constitution, was such an institution. Now, I'm not
sure. The courts seem to be politicized. Even the Constitution itself is the
subject of sophomoric chalk talks, foisted off on television viewers as
political analysis, while other commentators -- just as opinionated -- decorate
their rants with lines better men spoke in better times. Is it any wonder that
by now we view other opinions as, essentially, unreconcilable with our own?
The truth is unlikely to come to us from polemicists on the right or on the
left. It will come -- if it comes at all-- tentatively, in the form of a
dialogue, a collaboration. And the best collaborations take place inside the same
skull, inner dialogues, examinations of conscience, that proceed haltingly,
full of doubt. By their very nature, they must lack conviction, but lack of
conviction is popular culture's unforgivable sin. That such a dialogue can
occur any longer in the context of American pop culture is doubtful to say the
least.